A federal appeals court has overturned a rate increase that would have allowed BMI to collect higher licensing fees from certain music users, reshaping a long-running dispute over songwriter royalties.
In a recent decision, the U.S. Court of Appeals rejected a prior ruling that had approved higher rates for BMI’s public performance licenses. BMI, one of the largest performing rights organizations in the country, represents songwriters and publishers by collecting royalties when their music is played in public venues, on radio, or through digital services.
The rate change had applied to deals with broadcast television networks. The court determined that the lower court’s analysis contained errors, sending the matter back for further proceedings. BMI had argued the increase more accurately reflected the market value of its catalog, while broadcasters maintained the higher fees were not justified.
The ruling means existing rates remain in place for now. The decision could influence future negotiations between music rights organizations and major media companies, while leaving open the possibility of revised rates after further review.